Shelter Island hotels offer a variety of accommodations that cater to different preferences, from charming inns to luxurious retreats. Many are positioned near stunning beaches and provide easy access to various activities such as hiking, biking, and fishing.
Greenporter Hotel is situated just 9 minutes from Greenport and features 34 cozy rooms. The hotel offers access to amenities such as a swimming pool and a fitness suite. Located near East End Seaport Maritime Museum, guests can explore local attractions like the Fireboat Firefighter Museum and Railroad Museum of Long Island. Each room is equipped with ironing facilities and modern conveniences for a comfortable stay. Dining options nearby include The Frisky Oyster, a local favorite.
Located in Shelter Island Heights, Sunset Beach offers 20 luxurious rooms with breathtaking water views and balconies. The hotel is within walking distance of Crescent Beach. Guests can take advantage of the restaurant on-site, serving delicious local cuisine, as well as the various yoga classes available for leisure. The hotel's proximity to Greenport Antique Carousel adds an element of fun during your stay.
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast, located in East Marion, features beautifully appointed rooms with garden views. This property offers wellness packages along with a variety of outdoor activities, such as cycling and hiking. Situated near Lavender By the Bay Farm, guests can enjoy a serene environment perfect for relaxation. The bed and breakfast also provides a range of dining options, including a full breakfast to start your day.
The Blue Inn At North Fork is conveniently located just 5 minutes from Lavender By the Bay Farm. The inn features 20 comfortable rooms equipped with diverse amenities and offers a shared lounge and a garden terrace for relaxation. Guests can enjoy the swimming pool. The hotel's close proximity to the East End Seaport Maritime Museum provides cultural enrichment during your stay.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
186 US$
Beachfront Hotels in Shelter Island
Beachfront accommodations provide guests with direct access to sandy shores and breathtaking views, making them ideal for sunbathing, swimming, and beach activities. Many properties also offer on-site dining options to enjoy meals with stunning ocean backdrops.
The Pridwin Hotel is a stunning waterfront resort on Shelter Island, featuring 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages. Guests can savor delicious dishes at the on-site American restaurant while enjoying water views. The hotel also provides access to various seasonal activities for all ages, a full-service spa, and a scenic pool. Outdoor adventures such as hiking and boating allow for exploring the beautiful natural setting surrounding the property.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
334 US$
10.0
Good
(15 Reviews)
+ 47 photos
Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast
424 4Th Street 1 Miller Lane
Free Wi-Fi in rooms
Free parking
Baggage storage
Bar/ Lounge area
Outdoor dining area
Welcome drink
Seasonal outdoor pool
Heated swimming pool
Laundry
Flat-screen TV
Electric kettle
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Cycling
Canoeing
Fishing
Horseback riding
Golf course
Beach access
Private beach
Sun loungers
Beach umbrellas
Board games
No pets allowed
Air conditioning
No smoking on site
Show more +Show less -
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast is a charming beachfront property located in Greenport. The property features 5 guest rooms with beautiful views of the sea and garden, along with a private beach area for guests to relax. The seasonal outdoor swimming pool adds to the comfort of your stay. A wide range of bicycles for exploration and a bar are also available for guests at this inviting bed and breakfast.
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows offers guests a unique beachfront experience just 25 miles from Splish Splash. The motel features a tranquil atmosphere with a private beach area and a restaurant serving American cuisine. Each room is equipped with air conditioning, and certain units come with a terrace overlooking the sea. Guests can stay active with the complimentary bicycles offered by the motel.
Hotel Moraine is located near Greenport and offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and private beach access. The property features a shared lounge for relaxation and comfortable parking for guests. Each room includes a multi-channel TV and air conditioning for added comfort. Nature enthusiasts can explore local attractions such as Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum and Kontokosta Winery.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
828 US$
Hotels Near Shelter Island, NY
Staying near Shelter Island provides easy access to the island's attractions while also benefiting from the options available on the mainland, which often include diverse dining experiences and shopping opportunities. These hotels are well-positioned for both relaxation on Shelter Island and convenience for exploring the surrounding areas.
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn is a charming 4-star bed and breakfast in Greenport. Each air-conditioned unit includes modern amenities such as a flat-screen TV and Wifi. The inn provides opportunities for sightseeing tours and boasts proximity to local attractions. Guests can enjoy additional services such as bicycle rentals and on-site dining at the snack bar.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
447 US$
+ 22 photos
Fordham House
817 Main Street
Free Wi-Fi
Parking lot
Breakfast
Show more +Show less -
Fordham House is a cozy 3-star hotel just a short walk from the Greenport Antique Carousel. It features convenient amenities such as free Wi-Fi and on-site parking. The hotel's location provides easy access to Sandy Beach. Guests can enjoy the local dining scene with various restaurants nearby.
Located in Southold, Southold Beach Motel is a family-friendly option situated just steps from Hashamomuck Beach. It features comfortable accommodations and a sun terrace ideal for relaxation. Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property, enhancing guests' experience during their stay. The motel's location offers access to nearby attractions such as Lavender By the Bay Farm.
A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast is a charming accommodation located near Cedar Beach County Park. It provides guests with personalized breakfast options daily. The property features a terrace for relaxing outdoors and air-conditioned rooms equipped with modern amenities. Conveniently situated for access to local hiking trails, this bed and breakfast is an ideal option for those who love the outdoors.
Baron's Cove is a luxury hotel situated in Sag Harbor. The on-site restaurant serves fresh American cuisine and is popular for its brunch options. The property provides the convenience of complimentary bicycle rentals, allowing guests to explore the beautiful Sag Harbor area and nearby beaches easily.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
219 US$
Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Luxury accommodations in Shelter Island provide guests with upscale amenities, exquisite dining options, and prime locations that enhance the travel experience. Guests can indulge in spa services, opulent furnishings, and stunning views.
10.0
Good
(1 Reviews)
+ 45 photos
Hamptons Style North Fork Chill 3 Bedroom 2 Night Minimum
150 Mt Beulah Ave
Wi-Fi
Flat-screen TV
Show more +Show less -
The Hamptons Style North Fork Chill is a luxurious villa boasting three bedrooms and two bathrooms. It is nestled near cultural points of interest such as Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum. Guests can unwind in the sauna or enjoy the summer terrace and outdoor pool. The villa is equipped with a fully equipped kitchen for guests who prefer to cook their own meals during their stay.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Pet-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Pet-friendly accommodations allow guests to enjoy their stay without leaving their furry friends behind. These hotels often offer special amenities and services for pets.
Zey Hotel in Greenport offers a welcoming environment for pet owners, featuring air-conditioned rooms and a variety of amenities. Guests can enjoy free Wi-Fi, parking, and even an indoor play area for pets. The hotel is conveniently located near attractions like Kontokosta Winery. Bicycle rentals are also available for guests who wish to explore the surrounding area.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
599 US$
Dog-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island
Dog-friendly accommodations enable pet owners to relax knowing their companions are welcome. These properties may offer nearby pet-friendly parks and facilities.
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach is located just a stone's throw from the beach. The inn includes complimentary breakfast prepared each morning and features a picturesque garden area for relaxation. Each room is well-equipped with cable TVs and complimentary Wi-Fi. The property also boasts an on-site contemporary art gallery, providing an inviting atmosphere for guests.
American Beech Hotel allows guests to bring their pets along, featuring air-conditioned rooms and a welcoming garden area where pets can stretch their legs. Guests can take advantage of complimentary bicycle rentals to discover the scenic area or relax in the comfortable hotel lounge. With a focus on offering quality accommodations, guests can enjoy their stay knowing their furry friends are welcome.
Sound View Greenport is a pet-friendly property featuring a private beach area, perfect for guests traveling with dogs. The hotel has a seasonal outdoor pool for guests to enjoy and offers accommodations with a focus on comfort and convenience. Located near popular attractions like Montauk and East Hampton, guests can explore the surroundings with their pets by their side, creating memorable experiences together.
Shelter Island House is a dog-friendly boutique hotel, featuring a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and comfortable accommodations. The property's restaurant serves dishes created with locally sourced ingredients, appealing to food lovers. Guests can enjoy complimentary bicycles for exploring the area, allowing for convenient access to nearby attractions. With a welcoming ambiance for pets, the hotel ensures a memorable stay for all guests.
The Menhaden Hotel welcomes guests with pets. Located in the heart of Greenport, the hotel provides easy access to local attractions and restaurants. Guests can enjoy bicycle rentals for exploring the scenic surroundings.
Read moreShow less
Price comparison
Average Price
499 US$
Founded in 1652, Shelter Island is rich in history and natural beauty, home to attractions such as the Mashomack Preserve and the Shelter Island Historical Society. This 29.8-square-mile island offers a quaint, peaceful atmosphere interlaced with sandy beaches, marinas, and stunning waterfront views.
With numerous options, travelers can choose from 5-star luxury hotels, pet-friendly accommodations, and beachfront properties. Top-rated establishments, including intimate inns and lavish retreats, provide convenient access to local attractions and a comfortable base for exploring the surrounding Long Island region.
